AI is showing up in every corner of the workplace; from automating back-end systems to driving major product shifts. But what’s missing from the conversation is a pretty major piece of the puzzle that makes or breaks AI success: leadership.
It’s one thing to start investing in tools or announce an AI initiative; and it’s another to find leaders who know what that actually means and have the ability to guide teams through the messy (and often uncertain) middle. You’ll need people who understand the tech, think big-picture, and can get buy-in across departments and stakeholders.
This guide is here to help. We’ll walk through how to build a leadership team that’s ready to bring your AI goals to life.
Why AI leadership is different
Being a strong leader means knowing your product, managing risk, and hitting targets. And while those responsibilities are definitely still important, AI adds a whole new layer of complexity to the mix. You’re not only managing people and goals, you’re navigating nuance, ambiguity, and a flood of data.
Comparatively, AI leadership requires a different set of muscles. You have to understand what machine learning can actually do and how it can apply to your context. You’re making (often quick) decisions with real consequences, including when to slow down and think twice. There’s also the matter of translation. Engineers speak in algorithms and parameters, while stakeholders want to see clear ROI. AI leaders need to move between those worlds without losing the thread. It’s a lot to juggle.
Whether you’re launching a new product, improving internal systems, or simply trying to stay ahead of the curve, having the right leaders in place makes the difference. The companies pulling ahead in AI aren’t always the ones with the biggest budgets. Instead, they’re the ones with people who know how to build, guide, and scale wisely.
Key pain points in building AI leadership
Hiring strong AI leaders can feel like trying to find a needle in a haystack. The talent pool is small, demand is sky-high, and the stakes are real.
Here are the most common roadblocks companies face:
- Talent scarcity: AI professionals are already tough to hire for. Add in leadership skills like strategic thinking and cross-functional communication, and the list of qualified candidates shrinks fast. One company we spoke to spent nearly eight months trying to fill a head of AI role, and by the time they made an offer, the candidate had taken another job.
- Geographic limitations: Many companies look only within their city, country, or region. If you’re not in a major AI hub, you’re limiting your chances before you’ve even started. Meanwhile, top talent around the world is often overlooked.
- Mismatch between skills and leadership: This is good advice in general, but a great engineer doesn’t always make a great leader. We’ve seen brilliant data scientists promoted into leadership roles too soon, only to burn out or stall progress, and vice versa!
- Internal capability gaps: Existing leaders may not speak the language of AI or feel confident driving these initiatives. Some resist change, others feel lost in the jargon. That hesitation slows everything down.
These challenges are common, but thankfully there’s always a solution. Getting it right takes more than good intentions, however. It takes a thoughtful approach to hiring, training, and team design.
Step-by-step: How to build an AI-ready leadership team
Building a team that can lead AI work is about planning, clarity, and knowing what to look for. Here’s how to get started:
1. Define your AI vision and business goals. Before you bring in new people or platforms, get clear on what you want AI to do for your organization. What problem are you solving? Maybe it’s cutting costs, speeding up decision-making, or making your services more personalized. Whatever the goal, write it down. The more specific, the better. Instead of “we want to use AI internally,” try adding more details, context, and metrics: “We want to reduce manual processing time in customer onboarding by 40%.” This will help your future leaders plan and track team progress.
2. Assess current leadership capabilities. You might already have people with the potential to lead AI work. So, start by looking at your current team. Who shows curiosity about data and emerging tech? Who’s adaptable when things shift quickly? You don’t need everyone to be an AI expert, but you do need leaders who are willing to learn and can handle change. You can also bring in external assessments to measure data literacy and tech readiness.
3. Fill in the gaps with the right AI leaders. There may be circumstances where the folks on your team won’t have the right skill sets to get you to your AI objectives. In that case, you’ll want to bring in experienced AI leaders who can hit the ground running. That means finding people who understand the tech, can communicate across teams, and have seen what works (and what doesn’t) before.
This is where a smart search strategy pays off. At PowerToFly, our Executive Search specialists help organizations find leaders with deep AI experience. We align with your goals and culture to run targeted searches for hard-to-find talent. That includes candidates you won’t find by posting on job boards. Whether you need a Head of Machine Learning or a Chief Data Officer, we connect you with leaders who don’t just know AI — they know how to lead with it.
However you decide to go about it, when hiring for niche AI leadership roles, keep an eye out for:
- Cross-functional communication skills
- Strategic thinking
- A track record of building or scaling AI products
- Comfort with ambiguity and iteration
The goal is to find people who will shape your vision and help bring it to life.
4. Augment teams with global AI talent. Leadership isn’t only at the top. Your AI team needs technical leads who can manage sprints, guide junior engineers, and work side-by-side with product teams. But depending on your location, hiring those people can feel impossible due to time and budget constraints. Our suggestion is to expand your search to include highly-qualified individuals from places like LATAM, Eastern Europe, India, and across the U.S. This is a flexible, cost-effective way to grow without sacrificing quality. You get access to world-class talent, often in time zones that overlap with your existing team’s workday. And, let’s be honest: waiting six months to hire locally while your AI strategy stalls isn’t exactly a great plan. Scaling globally expands your options.
5. Upskill and empower your existing leaders. Not every leadership gap requires a new hire. Sometimes, your best AI leaders are already on your team. They just need the right tools and guidance to reach their potential. Training your current leaders in AI fluency, ethical decision-making, and strategic integration is one of the smartest moves you can make. The goal here isn’t to turn everyone into an engineer, it’s to help people speak the language of AI, ask better questions, and lead with clarity. This is a great way to empower your existing leaders, and help push your AI vision forward with an aligned, informed team.
Building a culture that supports AI leadership
Building a strong AI team with even stronger leaders is a daunting task. Trust us, we talk to teams struggling to do it every single day. It can be easy for leaders to default to finger-pointing, fear mongering, or total avoidance. But if your team is afraid to test, question, or fail…your AI plans will stall before they even get off the ground.
Strong AI leadership also depends on psychological safety. People need to feel empowered to speak up when models go sideways, be able to flag bias in data, and explore new ideas without worrying about making mistakes. That means leaders must model curiosity, transparency, and collaboration. Encourage teams to share learnings across departments. Pair engineers with product folks. Let marketing sit in on data reviews. AI works best when everyone has a seat at the table.
And remember: tools come and go, but culture sticks. The teams doing AI well are the ones where experimentation is rewarded, and decision-making is driven by both data and values. Build that foundation, and the tech will follow.
—
At PowerToFly, we help companies build AI-ready teams through executive search, global staff augmentation, and tailored upskilling programs. Whether you need someone to lead the charge or level up your current team, we’ve got you covered. Set up some time with one of our team members. It’s the first step to making your AI goals a reality and getting the right people on board to lead the way.
